Page 2 of 2

Posted: Sun Apr 08, 2007 6:50 pm
by Phil
Smitty wrote:
mick_dundee wrote:As best i'm aware Smitty there is no age restriction per se on carrying a pillion, meremy you have to have held your licence for 12 months and that the pillion can reach footpegs allocated to them.

Happy to be corrected if someone wants to provide the link to vicroads :)
Mick...........

per Vicroads (cut and paste)

blah blah


seems to all apply to L's or P's, again there was NOTHING in the original story that said he was an L or P plater........at 19 hey could have had a black licence.

still fail to see why it was plain stupid, i'm with neka (fark thats scary) sound like bad luck and shitty roadside hardware.........

Posted: Sun Apr 08, 2007 7:59 pm
by mrmina
i'm sure none of us have broken the law before.

maybe the bloke had an emergency or something that forced him to do it.

Lets no think negatively about our fellow bikers.

Posted: Sun Apr 08, 2007 10:48 pm
by Tenoq
In regards to pillion at 19 - it could easily be legal:

Minimum age for motorcycle learners: 18.
Minimum learner period: 3 months.
Restricted license period: 12 months.

19 & 3 months you could be on a litre bike with pillion: perfectly legal. Not really enough information to judge either guys - police saying speed was a factor is basically them saying they don't know what happened. Could have fallen asleep too, given the time of morning, or perhaps his brakes failed, or a million other things. Who knows?

Posted: Mon Apr 09, 2007 12:01 pm
by smek
Smitty wrote: Riding on a Probationary Licence
Including the above restrictions, if you are issued with a probationary motorcycle licence, the following restrictions apply until the end of your probationary period:
display a 'P' plate on the rear of the motorcycle only
zero BAC
yes it includes the above restrictions but they are still only in effect for the first 12 months. For the other two years of your P's there are no restrictions other than BAC and the plate.. I was riding a 6 with P plates.

Posted: Mon Apr 09, 2007 12:50 pm
by Shifty
Cam229 wrote:The only way a rider...could hit the signs on that roundabout meant that they have failed to slow down for the roundabout...
Cam, that's the kind of closed minded thinking that leads to more speed enforcement. That the rider has hit a directional sign is a given - that it was due to speed not so.

Early last year I crashed on a corner I've done hundreds of times. At the time, I was doing a speed below the posted limit and considerably lower than I have done previously around that same corner.

As far as I can work out (and I'm still not 100% sure) I took a pretty average line through the corner and when I realised I adjusted accordingly. Because of the brain fart I didn't have my body in the right position and had to lean the bike over a lot further than normal - in turn the stand grounded and the back wheel shot out from under me when the weight transferred. Bang, bike into guard rail, and luckily no bang for Shifty who went UNDER the guard rail after the bike had lifted it up and taken out the support rail.

Now had I been killed, the coppers (and you) would show up to the scene and say excessive speed was the cause of my accident. Which is not the case as I've done the same corner many times and much faster.... it was simply a fuckup and nothing more.

This guy could have braked poorly, the pillion could have moved suddenly & unsettled the bike, or he could have approached on the wrong line not being familiar with the road. At that time of day he woud likely be very tired & inattentive; be it after an all-nighter or having only just crawled out of bed.

An animal could have run across in front of him, he swerved to miss it, the pillion couldn't see it from his position behind the rider and the zero witnesses at 5am couldn't justify it either.

Remember that approaching a roundabout at 100km/h and washing off half your speed before crashing, leaves an identical mess to approaching at 60km/h, panic braking with the rear & only washing off 10km/h before you crash.

I'm not saying the accident where this rider was killed WASN'T speed, everything I know about 19yos riding sportsbikes tells me it probably was, but you can't just assume or you're no better than the closed-minded gits that would take my license away for doing 140km/h on a straight & open piece of country road with no intersections. Speed isn't the only killer and if you put a more experienced rider on that bike at whatever speed it was, they might very well be alive - they also might not.

Posted: Mon Apr 09, 2007 6:47 pm
by Gosling1
my 2c worth - I reckon the pillion has sat up the wrong way as he entered the roundabout, everyone knows what effect this has on steering..... :x

sad to hear about another biker death, regardless of the circumstances.

8)

Posted: Tue Apr 10, 2007 6:43 am
by Black Magic
Neka79 wrote:well i was riding a zx6r at 20..... and it woulda been a year earlier if i hadnt lost my P's and had to start from scratch....

maybe he was going to work??

how often do the cops blame "excessive speed" cos its the simple explaination??


FWIW one of the guys i ride with her use to ride a 92 cbr900..... the kid was 16 and out wheelied a lot of the other guys..and he had his mrs on the back...

then theres the stunter Colton (cant think of his 1st name) who is 16 and stunting a cbr600 better than most guys on the road...

stop blaming age, and the rider..he learnt the ultimate lesson...as did his family..if he was guilty, he got a harsh sentence..if he wasnt guilty, then unfortunately he didnt get a chance to learn from this...

we get enuf negative criticism from cops,pollies and cagers, so lets stand up for one of our own...
I agree with neka.
Whenever there is a bike involved the rider is made out to be some sort of gangster. If it is a cage in the accident people don't automatically assume that speed, alcohol or stupidity were involved.
Maybe these factors did play a part, but we weren't there to know.
Condolances to the friends and family, and get well wishes to the pillion.

Posted: Tue Apr 10, 2007 10:13 am
by red_dave
I've stacked it doinw 60ish in a 80 zone, and 15ish in a carpark... :oops:

No doubt speed can kill, but so can falling down stairs, or drinking drain-o... :roll:

Posted: Tue Apr 10, 2007 10:54 pm
by Neka79
red_dave wrote:I've stacked it doinw 60ish in a 80 zone, and 15ish in a carpark... :oops:

No doubt speed can kill, but so can falling down stairs, or drinking drain-o... :roll:
u woulda been ok if u hadda got urself sum of that tank foam...

Posted: Wed Apr 11, 2007 7:44 am
by Phil
Neka79 wrote:
red_dave wrote:I've stacked it doinw 60ish in a 80 zone, and 15ish in a carpark... :oops:

No doubt speed can kill, but so can falling down stairs, or drinking drain-o... :roll:
u woulda been ok if u hadda got urself sum of that tank foam...
or a reflective vest :lol: